It pulls at your gut and rises like a fire in your throat and face that washes over you in a flood of shame. On the inside, you have a burning feeling of regret, disappointment, and slight panic. On the outside, because you are a professional, you smile and agree. You nod your head with reluctance and speak in your most convincing tone, but you pause so as not to say too many words. You want to be honest. You want to do right by your cherished patient who you have grown to love over the years. You also want to keep your job.
What if that feeling of exhaustion and discontent with being a hygienist one more day and picking up one more scaler is not burnout? What if it is not burnout from long hours, static positioning, repetitive movements, compassion fatigue, or patients who are noncompliant or combative? What if, instead, it is the emotional labor of repeatedly finding ourselves in situations that conflict with our values, ethics, and sense of professional purpose, and the inner turmoil of moral injury?
Moral Injury versus Burnout
Moral injury was originally introduced to psychotraumatology as “the lasting psychological, biological, spiritual, behavioral, and social impact of perpetrating, failing to prevent, or bearing witness to acts that transgress deeply held moral beliefs and expectations.”1 Though originally studied in combat veterans, moral injury has more recently been identified in healthcare providers.2
Exposure to experiences that deeply betray a person’s moral alignment, also known as potentially morally injurious events (PMIEs), may cause healthcare providers to experience moral distress. When circumstances prevent clinicians from providing the patient care or support they believe is needed, persistent moral distress can lead to moral injury. This stems from knowing the right thing to do but feeling unable to do it because of systemic barriers, organizational constraints, or concerns about personal or professional consequences.1,2 Healthcare providers can suffer from depression, changes in mood and habits, increased mistakes, isolation, and perhaps compulsive behaviors resulting from these feelings of guilt, shame, anger, or betrayal.3
Unlike moral injury, which arises from moral violations due to dysfunction in a system’s policies and practices, burnout occurs when prolonged occupational stress from workplace demands leads to exhaustion. Despite this distinction, moral injury may disguise itself in the pillars of burnout: emotional exhaustion, ineffectiveness, and depersonalization.1,2 However, moral injury goes beyond burnout, as it may cause a provider to reassess their professional purpose and feel as though they no longer belong in the space of caregiving.2 There is often a sense of, “this isn’t what I thought it was going to be.”
Moral Injury in Dental Hygiene
As hygienists, we enter this profession to improve health, elevate quality of life, and live by the oath we took at pinning. Over time, repeated experiences of not being able to provide patients with what they deserve add up. These experiences are rarely dramatic: knowing the patient needs more time, more education, or more resources. When we are unable to provide those things, it eventually spills over like an unattended coffee pot that can hold only one more drop. We may feel tired, but the real issue is that we no longer feel like the clinician we intended to be.
For instance, appointment times are often shortened to accommodate scheduling demands or production goals. Reduced patient access to treatment or education may cause the hygienist to experience tension between efficiency and their professional standards of care. Moral injury can occur when the clinician dismisses patients knowing they did not provide the appropriate level of care.1,2
Moral distress may arise when clinical judgment and philosophy differ regarding periodontal findings and treatment recommendations. Repeatedly experiencing an inability to reconcile these differences can leave the clinician’s integrity feeling challenged.1
In some settings, administrative personnel influence scheduling and operational clinical decisions. Although these roles are integral to the practice, tension builds when clinicians feel scheduling practices do not align with patient-centered care.1,2
Recognizing and Addressing Moral Injury
Brenton Guice, RDH, LPC, owner of The Mental Hug, a mental health therapy practice in Kansas City, Missouri, has firsthand experience with moral injury through his lens as a seasoned dental hygienist and his work with counseling clients. Guice states that when dental hygienists face reduced appointment times or other pressures, they lose their connection with patients. He reminisces that, like most of us, he entered this profession to help improve patients’ oral health. Rushed or abbreviated appointments may leave us feeling like a “working mill” instead of healthcare providers. Guice hits on an important reminder: “On the other side of production pressure is a provider who longs for the joy and passion of the work that brought them to dentistry in the first place. The longing for that joy and passion may feel like burnout, but so much of it is moral injury.”4
Guice advises to first get in touch with the feelings by recognizing and naming them. Many clinicians assume they are burned out, but upon deeper introspection, may discover the pain stems from repeated encounters with conflicting professional values.4 Identifying moral injury can help ease shame that often accompanies these experiences by reframing the distress as a response to value struggles rather than personal failure.
Next, identify the value that was violated.5 When distressed, ask a simple question like, “What value of mine feels threatened right now?” Consider what you value versus what is being violated. For example, I value patient education, providing quality care, honesty and transparency, patient advocacy, and practicing evidence-based preventive care. Just naming the value can be validating.
Embrace what you can and cannot control.5 Remembering that things like insurance limitations, staffing shortages, organizational policies, or other providers’ decisions are out of our control can help us focus on what we can control. We can often take charge of setting boundaries, staying out of office drama triangles, advocating for patients by offering proper resources, deciding whether the office aligns with our values enough to continue the relationship, and choosing how we communicate our concerns. Speaking up and advocating for yourself in a professional manner does not always mean confrontation. Explore ways to respectfully voice your views and concerns based on evidence-based recommendations and through collaborative conversations.
Moral injury thrives in isolation.5 Seek out your fellow dental hygienists. Being in community with other clinicians can help you see that you are not alone as well as validate your feelings and experiences. This is not simply about having a place to vent, as venting can breed a misery-loves-company environment, but about creating an opportunity to share and strategize ideas for getting involved in advocacy. Attending in-person conferences and courses, seeking out association groups, or creating local hygiene meet-ups can spark discussion, support, and mentorship.
Have a conversation with yourself about the sustainability of your work environment. Repeated exposure to value conflicts, even after they have been professionally discussed, may warrant deeper reflection on the fit of the office and whether it is, indeed, your long-term dental home. Perhaps it is time to explore other employment options that allow for moral security and sustenance.
In Closing
Dental hygienists enter the profession with a sense of deep care and concern for patients’ health and well-being, but ongoing injury to moral values can leave them harboring feelings of dissatisfaction and weariness. While providers cannot control every aspect or situation that arises, they can learn to discern between burnout and an attack on their professional values. Control what you can, seek guidance and support, and communicate professionally when those values and realities collide.
Before you leave, check out the Today’s RDH self-study CE courses. All courses are peer-reviewed and non-sponsored to focus solely on high-quality education. Click here now.
Listen to the Today’s RDH Dental Hygiene Podcast Below:
References
- von Ungern-Sternberg, B.S., Sommerfield, A., Becke-Jakob, K. Moral Injury in Clinical and Academic Medicine–It Is Time to Act. BJA Open. 2026; 17: 100525. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12859220/
- Dean, W., Morris, D., Manzur, M.K., Talbot, S. Moral Injury in Health Care: A Unified Definition and its Relationship to Burnout. Fed Pract. 2024; 41(4): 104-107. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11468615/
- Watson, P., Norman, S.B., Maguen, S., Hamblen, J. (2026, September 1). Moral Injury in Health Care Workers. U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs: National Center for PTSD. https://www.ptsd.va.gov/professional/treat/cooccurring/moral_injury_hcw.asp.
- Guice, B. Personal Interview, June 2026.
- Litz, B.T., Walker, H.E. Moral Injury: An Overview of Conceptual, Definitional, Assessment, and Treatment Issues. Annu Rev Clin Psychol. 2025; 21(1): 251-277. https://www.annualreviews.org/content/journals/10.1146/annurev-clinpsy-081423-022604
