Ask Kara RDH: New Hygienist Doing Inferior Work

© Ocskay Mark / Adobe Stock

I have 33 years experience and have worked in my current office for 13 years. I take pride in my care of my patients. We deal with a lot of perio, have successful results with SRP, and refer when needed. The doctors hired a new hygienist. I have brought to their attention a few situations where at the four-month recall after she performs treatment, the perio situation has declined at an alarming rate. There are also situations where heavy radiographic calculus remained after SRP. And I mean heavy! I’ve had to redo SRPs for her. When communicating my concerns with the doctors, they ask me what they and I can do to help her improve her skills. I am at a loss.

Assuming this isn’t a home care issue on the patient’s part, and the new hygienist needs help with instrumentation, the only thing you can really do is sit with her and work on it. She could also brush up on her skills by watching YouTube videos on instrumentation or even going to workshops on instrumentation (like at a dental conference). Hands-on is obviously a better option. I know this requires extra work on your part, but being a seasoned hygienist, showing her where to improve could be a positive influence on her. (Hopefully anyway, some people are not open to constructive criticism, and some people get defensive when they know they aren’t doing their best work.)

However, before sitting down with the hygienist, the doctors talk to her about it. This will avoid a potentially awkward situation where the newer hygienist feels you are telling her what to do and trying to be her boss. In reality, this situation is ultimately in the doctors’ hands, not yours.

Also, I dislike even saying or recommending this, but the doctors may want to check her work when they are doing their exam, so patients don’t have to come back and retreat. It would help her learn where she needs to focus, but on the other hand doing this could be  degrading to do in front of a patient. So that’s a double-edged sword. I only say it because not providing quality care, which ends up needing to be re-done, is not only a disservice to a patient, but the time taken to retreat will affect the office’s bottom line. Patients could be lost over this as well, due to the lack of confidence in the treating clinicians. Again, this is a situation the doctor/boss/owner of the practice needs to be dealing with, not you.

This is a tough one because you care about all the patients the practice treats, but ultimately you only have control over the treatment you provide. I wish you and her the best of luck!

Previous articleA New Era of Temping for the Dental Hygienist
Next articleResearch Links Poor Dental Hygiene to Low Birth Weight & Preterm Babies
Kara Vavrosky, RDHEP
Kara Vavrosky, RDHEP, is a Co-founder and the Chief Content Officer of Today’s RDH. Kara is a writer of popular articles that share practical advice and tips for hygienists, all in an informative and entertaining way. Beyond light-hearted content, Kara writes researched articles on topics in dental hygiene that educate hygienists on best practices and current protocols.

A graduate of the Oregon Institute of Technology, Kara has a deep passion for spreading knowledge about the importance of oral health and how it relates to the entire body. Kara’s passion extends to helping other hygienists understand the latest protocols, products, and research — all with the goal to push the profession forward.

Kara lives in Vancouver, WA with her fiancé Ben, and their rescued Chihuahua fur-babies, Bug & Lily. Beyond her love of dental hygiene, Kara enjoys spending time with her family, riding the Oregon dunes on her quads, and exploring the beautiful Pacific Northwest and all it has to offer.